Forfeitures are a common part of administering a 401(k) plan, but how they are managed can have significant implications for compliance and fiduciary responsibilities. With evolving IRS guidance and increased ERISA litigation, plan sponsors should understand when forfeitures occur, how they can be used, and why accurate recordkeeping matters.
Whether your plan has a small forfeiture balance or funds that have accumulated over several years, taking a proactive approach can help reduce compliance risks and ensure plan assets are handled appropriately.
What is a forfeiture?
A forfeiture generally occurs when a participant terminates employment before becoming fully vested in employer contributions. The participant keeps the vested portion of their account, while the nonvested portion may become a forfeiture under the terms of the plan document.
Once forfeited, those amounts generally remain plan assets and must be handled in accordance with the plan document. The IRS proposed regulations on the use of forfeitures identify three permitted uses for defined contribution plans, to the extent provided by the plan:
- Pay plan administrative expenses;
- Reduce employer contributions; or
- Increase benefits in other participants’ accounts in accordance with the terms of the plan.
The plan document remains critical. As a sponsor, you should not assume that each permissible use under IRS guidance is necessarily permitted by your plan.
How long can forfeitures remain in the plan?
In 2023, the IRS issued proposed regulations clarifying when forfeitures in defined contribution plans must be used. Under the proposal, forfeitures generally must be used within 12 months after the end of the plan year in which they occur. For example, forfeitures incurred in 2026 by a calendar-year plan would need to be used by December 31, 2027. The proposal also includes a transition rule allowing forfeitures incurred in plan years beginning before January 1, 2024, to be treated as incurred in the first plan year beginning on or after that date.
Although these regulations have not been finalized, plan sponsors may rely on them in the meantime. Sponsors should regularly review forfeiture balances, ensure funds are used in accordance with plan provisions, and avoid carrying unused balances forward unnecessarily.
Why have forfeitures become a litigation issue?
Forfeiture practices have become a focus of ERISA litigation, with class-action lawsuits challenging plans that use forfeitures to reduce employer contributions rather than pay plan expenses. Plaintiffs argue that using forfeitures for expenses could reduce costs charged to participants. While many decisions have favored plan sponsors, outcomes have varied. The Department of Labor has supported sponsors’ ability to offset employer contributions when permitted by the plan document.
In May 2026, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of Matula v. Wells Fargo & Company because the participant lacked standing, without resolving the underlying fiduciary-duty claims. Other cases remain in litigation, highlighting the importance of plan language and consistent practices.
For plan sponsors, using forfeitures to reduce employer contributions is not inherently prohibited. However, forfeiture practices should align with plan provisions, applicable regulations, and fiduciary obligations, with decisions documented consistently.
Why shouldn’t uncashed checks be confused as a true forfeiture?
Not every amount credited to a forfeiture account represents forfeited employer contributions. Sponsors should review account activity to identify any uncashed or returned participant distribution checks, which generally represent benefits still owed to participants and should not automatically be treated as forfeitures available for other plan purposes.
The Department of Labor (DOL) emphasizes the importance of maintaining accurate participant records and following appropriate procedures for locating missing participants and beneficiaries. When distribution checks remain uncashed or are returned, plan fiduciaries should identify the affected participants, investigate the outstanding payments, make reasonable efforts to locate recipients, preserve their benefit entitlements, and document their actions.
As a plan sponsor, it’s important that as you review forfeiture accounts, you do more than simply ensure that funds have been used on time. Regular reconciliation is essential to understanding account balances, identifying misclassified amounts, and protecting participant benefits.
A practical checklist for plan sponsors
At least annually, if not more frequently, as a plan sponsor, you should:
- Review the plan document to determine when forfeitures occur and the permitted uses of forfeitures.
- Obtain a forfeiture account rollforward from the recordkeeper showing beginning balance, additions, uses, and ending balance.
- Investigate additions to the account to confirm they represent legitimate forfeitures.
- Identify returned or uncashed participant checks and make sure they have not been treated as ordinary forfeitures.
- Review aging to identify forfeitures approaching the applicable deadline.
- Confirm how forfeitures were used and verify that the use agrees with the plan document.
- Coordinate with the recordkeeper or third-party administrator before year-end to determine how any remaining balance will be used.
- Document the process, particularly where the plan document permits more than one use for forfeitures.
Final thoughts
Although forfeiture accounts may represent a small portion of a retirement plan’s assets, improper management can create significant compliance and fiduciary risks. With evolving IRS guidance and ongoing ERISA litigation, plan sponsors should take a proactive approach to reviewing their forfeiture practices.
Regular reviews should confirm that forfeitures are accurately classified, used within applicable timeframes, and handled in accordance with plan provisions. As a sponsor, you should also work with your recordkeepers, third-party administrators, and other advisors to address outstanding balances, maintain proper documentation, and protect participant benefits.
We’re here to help
SEK’s Employee Benefit Plan Audit team can help plan sponsors identify potential compliance concerns and strengthen plan administration practices. Contact our team to discuss your plan’s forfeiture procedures and how to prepare for a smoother, more efficient audit.

