Hiring the right employee is an important decision for any organization, but for nonprofits, where resources are often limited and every team member plays a role in advancing the mission, the stakes can feel even higher. After reviewing applications and conducting interviews, you may find yourself with several qualified candidates who could bring value to your organization. While having multiple strong applicants is a good problem to have, it can also make the final decision more difficult. When candidates have similar qualifications and experience, how do you determine who is the best fit? Here are four factors to consider when making your final hiring decision.
Their qualifications match, but their work style may not.
Skills and experience are only part of what makes someone a successful employee. A candidate may have the right qualifications but struggle to collaborate with your existing team or adapt to your work environment. Consider how each candidate communicates, approaches challenges, and works with others. Focus on job-related behaviors rather than personality similarities, as diverse perspectives can strengthen your organization.
Their salary requirements are not in line with your budget.
Nonprofits often operate within tight budgets, making compensation an important consideration. While some flexibility in salary negotiations can help attract qualified candidates, it’s important to recognize your financial limitations. Consider whether benefits such as flexible scheduling or professional development opportunities could help bridge the gap. If you cannot reach an agreement, it may be best to move forward with another candidate.
You have questions about their ability to perform the job.
A strong resume doesn’t always guarantee success in a position. If you have concerns about a candidate’s ability to perform essential responsibilities, consider asking follow-up questions, conducting a skills assessment, or checking professional references. These additional steps can help you make an informed decision rather than relying solely on your initial impressions.
They demonstrate concerning behavior during the interview.
An interview can reveal important information about a candidate’s professionalism and judgment. Speaking negatively about former colleagues, avoiding responsibility for past mistakes, or making inappropriate comments may raise concerns. However, it’s important to distinguish genuine red flags from nervousness or an awkward response. Consider the context and evaluate candidates consistently.
Making the right hiring decision
When several candidates appear equally qualified, evaluating these additional factors can help you make a confident, informed decision. The goal isn’t simply to fill an open position, but to find someone who can contribute to your nonprofit’s long-term success.
If your nonprofit needs support, SEK’s Nonprofit and Outsourced HR teams are here to help you navigate everything from budgeting to recruiting and more. Contact us using the form on this page to get started.
© 2026
